Whistle, hum, tap or drum your music straight into your Mac - Whistler will do the rest. Using advanced technology to make music production feasible and fun, Whistler is both a unique new studio tool for professionals and a musical instrument for us all.

Bloggers' Opinions:

...by far the most interesting idea is Richard Whitelock's Whistler - the concept is just genius; you just whistle a tune, or drum a beat using the microphone in your Mac and it turns it into a live midi track you can use in GarageBand!
David Emery Link

The bottom line is, this is very doable and offers a hugely viable concept commercially if successful... ...The potential for utility and entertainment both are immense, and if executed properly would be established as one of the legendary few applications to revolutionize the user experience on Mac OS X.
Rageous Music Link



...there's one idea that stands head and shoulders above the rest in my opinion - Richard Whitelock's Whistler.As an idea, it knocks my socks off... ...It's what a computer app should be - a perfect portal between CPU power and the user. Utterly fabulous, Mr Whitelock. I want.
Abroad at Home Link

MDA Developer & Judge Opinions:

This is just awesome. Someone make it, please. The greatest thing an application can do is allow users to do something that was once too difficult or complex to be feasible...Whistler would be a useful tool and a phenomenally fun toy.
Nicholas Jitkoff (Quicksilver)

the one I am most dying to play with by far...borderline revolutionary
Bill Bart (The Skins Factory)

I adore this idea... ...Whoo, Whistler...
I love this idea, and it'd be fun to code.
Jason Harris (Shapeshifter)

I just want to write two things about this idea - congratulations and oh my God does it look sweet! Whistler introduces a completely new way of interfacing with sound editing apps, which is so intuitive and simply human, that I'm actually astonished that I've never heard about it before.
Piotr Gajos (Inventive)

this idea - which might at first seem technically ridiculous - is actually probably quite possible and could be amazingly awesome
Cabel Sasser (Panic)

This concept is pure brilliance incarnate.
Bill Bart (The Skins Factory)

Voter Opinions:

Whistler could find a place pre-installed on new Macs. I'd happily pay for it if it wasn't

Whistler is clearly the standout. Layout, and design is one thing, and innovation is another.

I don't care who wins, but some apps (like Whistler), I really, really want to buy.

Whistler - A brilliant and innovative idea.

this is the most original app idea submitted.

Heck, if you had a presale on it now, with the realistic possibility it wouldn't get made, I'd still buy it.

Today was the first time I read through all the descriptions on this site, and when I read yours - boom!

WIN WIN WIN!!!!!

Whistler = greatness...

I have been making a point in trying not to express too much enthusiasm for contenders. But I cannot help but look wide-eyed at Whistler... ...This should be taken very seriously.

Vote Whistler! This app must be made! I feel like it's the only compelling app in the running that probably won't just be made anyway...

Get the word out on this app so it has a chance.

I have long wanted an application exactly like this

This app is by far my favorite contestant. And I want to reinforce Richard's point that it would be used by everybody.

Whistler could be ever so fantastic. So make it.